Handling Replies

What to Do When You Get a Positive Reply

Positive reply received - now what? Speed matters. Learn the optimal response process to convert interest into meetings.

4 min read

Speed Wins

The single biggest factor in converting a positive reply: how fast you respond.

Response TimeMeeting Book Rate
Under 1 hour3x higher
1-4 hours2x higher
Same dayBaseline
Next day50% lower
48+ hoursVery low
Respond within hours, not days.

Our Notification System

When we detect a positive reply:

  • Instant email notification - To your main inbox
  • SMS alert (if enabled) - For critical leads
  • Dashboard flag - Hot lead indicator

How to Respond

Reply from your main business email - Not the cold outreach domain.

This is intentional:

  • Your main email has better reputation
  • Ongoing conversation should be from real address
  • Cold email domains are for prospecting only

Response Template

Keep it simple:

``

Hi [Name],

Thanks for getting back to me. I'd love to set up a quick call to discuss [specific thing they mentioned].

Would [Day 1] at [Time] or [Day 2] at [Time] work for you?

[Your name]

[Your title]

[Your company]

`

What NOT to Do

MistakeWhy It's Bad
Long responseThey asked a simple question
More sellingThey're already interested
Delayed responseMomentum lost
From cold email domainConfuses the relationship
Automated responseKills the human touch

If They Asked a Question

Answer it directly, then offer next step:

`

Great question - [direct answer].

Would it help to discuss this briefly on a call? I'm free [times].

``

Don't dodge questions to "save" info for the call.

Scheduling Tips

  • Offer specific times (not "let me know when you're free")
  • 2-3 options max
  • Include timezone
  • Calendar link is fine for second message

Key Takeaway

Speed matters more than perfection. Respond within hours from your main email address. Keep it short. Make it easy to book time.

Put This Into Practice

Ready to apply these best practices? Our $299 setup includes 10 domains, Microsoft 365 licenses, and up to 10,000 verified leads - everything you need to get started.

Related Guides